Did the Health Savings Account (HSA) revolution take hold, or has it been a failure? The introduction of the HSA plan back in 2004 recived about as much fanfare and publicity as our newly elected President. Everyone from President Bush and congress to every local newspaper were touting their virtues. Have the HSA plans delivered? Have they lived up to expectations? Well, the answer is both yes and no, however they had a very rocky start. First, lets explain what is an HSA exactly.
To keep matters short I won’t get into deep detail regarding the tax advantages HSA’s can offer to the Texas health insurance consumer. Bottom line regarding the tax advantages you are allowed to contribute up to a set amount into an IRA fund and withdraw monies for medical expenses. If you wish to know more about the tax advantages there are thousands of websites explaining the matter in more detail.
HSA plans are very simple plans, you have one deductible to meet for all insured family members, unlike your traditional PPO doctor co-pay plans which generally have two or three deductible per family. Most times the deductibles hover around $6000 per family. After the deductible has been met the plans that I write generally pay 100% after the deductible. Most PPO doctor co-pay plans then pay at the traditional eighty-twenty co-insurance. So HSA plans DO offer potentially lower out of pockets in the event a family has a major sickness or injury. There are some agents in the Texas health insurance market that do write HSA plans with higher deductibles and out of pockets but for the most part I see the Texas HSA plans with about the before mentioned six grand out of pocket.
So far so good, right? Well unfortunately wrong. Here is where they start to differ from their major medical sisters. HSA plans apply all medical expenses to the deductible. A Texas health insurance consumer can not have doctor visits and drug prescriptions covered until the deductible has been met, otherwise they fall out of compliance with federal IRS guidelines. The new trend with HSA plans is to cover a limited amount of preventive care before the deductible has been met, however the numbers that don’t cover preventive still out number the ones that do at this point. So simply put a client that goes to the doctor for the common cold or flu will pay all expenses out of pocket up until a point the family deductible has been met.
Texas health insurance consumers should understand that they are buying a straight high deductible plan with no additional benefits when they purchase an HSA plan from a Texas health insurance agent. Period. Clients that rank having doctor visits covered and drug prescription coverage with a co-pay are not ideal clients for these plans. The family will be very unhappy if they allow a Texas health insurance agent to convince them these plans are the right fit for them.
I find that Texas HSA plans work well for those families that have no children or the kids in the family are teenagers. I have also found the HSA plans work well for families that are over fifty-five, as they rarely go to the doctor. Texas consumers that buy the HSA and have a couple of kids under six could be very disappointed in the performance of their Texas health insurance policy.
One interesting note about HSA plans, they are the easiest plans to understand out of all the plans in the Texas health insurance marketplace. It’s simple, meet the deductible, plan kicks in.
In most cases HSA plans offer much lower monthly premiums than your traditional doctor co-pay plans. In some cases the monthly price drop can be a couple hundred dollars a month. That’s a substantial savings for consumers that are experiencing the financial hardships that our present economy is causing.
So to summarize, the HSA plan is great for families that do not go to the doctor often and they also provide some semblance of a cost certain on out of pocket expenses, however if you are someone that needs the doctor co-pay for the times you take your children to the doctor, and need the drug prescription co-pay the HSA will not work for you.
I think the HSA plans have not taken off in popularity as much as congress and some very single minded Texas health insurance agents thought they would. Who knows, maybe they someday will, I just dont think you can ever replace the mindset of having a doctor co-pay, so I think the plans will only be a marginal player in the Texas health insurance marketplace.
I do feel if you rarely use your coverage and are getting pinched by the extremely high premiums of today’s Texas health plans, get a quote today. They might well work for you, but if your expecting something that more resembles group coverage stay with your PPO doctor co-pay plan, otherwise unhappiness is just around the corner.




